Cherish All Lives

I disagree with the Black Lives Matter movement on just about everything, but I admire their brilliant choice of a motto.  They've picked something that no one could possibly disgree with.  Of course black lives matter!  But what does that mean?  Well, it was started in reference to police killings of blacks, so it must imply that we have to cut down on that.  But how?  Defund the police?  That doesn't follow, and it's far from something everyone would agree with.  Somehow, however, people who agree that black lives matter find themselves swept up in the defund the police movement.  And since police obviously aren't going to be totally defunded, they start thinking about what else they can do to stay on the right side, the safe side.  That begins by putting "black lives matter" on all their web sites and telling people that we must do more to stop racism -- which is quite a jump from the bland assertion that black lives matter.

Saying "black lives matter" is inherently racial, but it's also obvious, so it appears like a neutral statement.  So much so that people who counter with "all lives matter" are considered racist, even though "all lives matter" doesn't mention race and "black lives matter" does.  Why would it be racist?  Because it seems to deny the reality that black lives are not valued in our society and blacks are killed, mistreated, and generally undervalued disproportionately.  Never mind if there is actually any evidence to support that "reality."  If you agree that "black lives matter," you must agree with it; and if you assert that all lives matter, you must not agree with it, and therefore you must not think that black lives matter.  Thus the power of a slogan to direct thought.

I like to come up with effective titles and slogans, so I have given some thought to this issue.  It is difficult to counter "Black Lives Matter," and "All Lives Matter" clearly isn't doing it.  I think the counter slogan needs to be more active.  The power of "Black Lives Matter" lies in the way it implies that society does not think black lives matter.  Saying "All Lives Matter" is obviously a response to "Black Lives Matter," but without the implicit idea that society doesn't value all lives.  ("Blue Lives Matter" was more effective, I thought, but it is also very particular.)  The counter-slogan needs to be something that poses the same implicit contradiction to society's actual values, and preferably something more active that just saying "something matters."

The best I can come up with at the moment is, "Cherish All Lives."  This implies that society does not cherish all lives, and that we need to do so.  It encompasses "Black Lives Matter" because, if it is true that black lives are not valued, then clearly anyone who believes "Cherish All Lives" must believe that this is a wrong that needs to be corrected.  But it also gives us room to say that police lives matter, white lives matter, even disagreeable people's lives matter:  it's not about race or ideology, but about love and humanity.  If you truly believe that all lives matter, then I think you should believe that we need to Cherish All Lives.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Science and Philosophy, Part I: Hume and Popper

I've been listening to a lecture series on philosophy recently, and, even though I haven't gotten past the Greeks yet, it has reminded me of a number of issues that trouble me about science. I want to take the opportunity to express my concerns here. Along the way, I will probably oversimplify philosophy a great deal -- not on purpose, but rather because I have only a simplistic understanding of it. I welcome responses to clear up my misconceptions. One of my issues with science is the famous idea of Karl Popper that it can never establish positive claims, only falsify wrong ones. The history of this goes back to David Hume, the 18th century Scottish sceptic. He shook up the philosophical world by claiming that science could never prove anything through induction -- that is, drawing conclusions about physical laws based on observations. The classic illustration is the sun's rising. Even though the sun has risen every day for our whole lives, and for countless human l
Read more

Country Music

I noticed a long time ago that there isn't much difference between the sound of country music and rock music nowadays. If I'm surfing my radio and I come to a station playing jazz, classical, or rap, I recognize it right away; but if I come to a country or rock station, I often can't tell which it is until the song is half over. Country songs often have screaming guitars that would fit equally well in a hard rock song, and only a minority have a recognizably country instrument such as a fiddle or a banjo. All the same, no one could listen to a country music station for more than a few minutes without realizing that it is definitely not a rock station. What are the differences? There are some stylistic differences. Country songs are more likely to have a boogey beat or certain western-sounding bass lines. They also tend to be more formulaic: if you can't predict how a country song ends, you probably don't listen to much country music. But those things aren'
Read more

What Are Pronouns For?

 Here's what I don't get about people defining their own pronouns (and I use "their" advisedly):  If I am talking to you, your pronoun is "you."  No one disputes that.  If I am talking about you to another person, the pronoun I use to reference you is none of your business.  I am in a conversation with someone else; you are not a party to it, and you are not entitled to impose rules on it.  Ideally, you will never know what we say -- but if you do find out, it doesn't matter because the pronouns I used were for my convenience, not for your feelings.  Heck, I may not even have met you, may not have any idea what you identify as or even what sex you really are (as sometimes happens when people have names like "Leslie" or "Ashley" that get used for both sexes, or foreign names that I am unfamiliar with).  So mind your business and there will be nothing to get offended about.
Read more